Meeting of the Hawke's Bay Regional Council

 

 

Date:                 Wednesday 10 May 2017

Time:                1.00pm

Venue:

Council Chamber

Hawke's Bay Regional Council

159 Dalton Street

NAPIER

 

Attachments Excluded From Agenda

 

item       subject                                                                                                                   page

 

3.         Review of the Ruataniwha Water Storage Scheme

Attachment 4:      Ruataniwha Water Storage Scheme Review Report                       3

Attachment 5:      Issue 1 Appendix 1 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 29Nov16 Cover Letter                                                                                                        88

Attachment 6:      Issue 1 Appendix 2 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 29Nov16 Land Swap Appeal Opinion                                                                               89

Attachment 7:      Issue 2 Appendix 3 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 27Mar17 RWSS Withdrawal Process                                                                        96

Attachment 8:      Issue 2 Appendix 4 Lara Bloomfield SLW PC6 without RWSS Liability Opinion 27Mar17                                                                          103

Attachment 9:      Issue 2 Appendix 5 HBRC Public Notice PC6 4May13                104

Attachment 10:   Issue 3 Appendix 6 Blair O'Keeffe Bell Gully 7Apr17 Memorandum RWSS shelving costs and liabilities                                                         105

Attachment 11:   Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review                                                                                          107

Attachment 12:   Issues 6 & 8 Appendix 8 Chris Morrison Lewis Tucker April 2017 Commercial Review Report                                                          154

Attachment 13:   Issue 7 Appendix 9 Advice on barriers to faster uptake Blair O'Keeffe 17Mar17                                                                                        169

Attachment 14:   Issue 9 Appendix 10 Grant Pechey HBRC Butcher Report Summary 040517                                                                                          171

Attachment 15:   Issue 10 Appendix 11 Tom Skerman 10Apr17 Downstream Production Demand                                                                                         188

Attachment 16:   Issue 12 Appendix 12 Ned Norton 7Apr17 Nutrient Leaching     195

Attachment 17:   Issue 12 Appendix 13 Memo Lachie Grant &  Ian Millner On-farm management practices                                                                 211

Attachment 18:   Issue 12 Appendix 14 WQE Memo from Andy Hicks to Ned Norton 13Apr17                                                                                         231

Attachment 19:   Issue 12 Appendix 15 Dougall Gordon 21Feb17 Groundwater Nitrate State and Trends Assessment                                                     239

Attachment 20:   Issue 13 Appendix 16 Nathan Heath 6Apr17 PC6 without RWSS 250

Attachment 21:   Issue 13 Appendix 17 Nathan Heath HBRC Appendices  6Apr17 258

Attachment 22:   Issue 14 Appendix 18 John Bright Aqualinc 7Apr17 Tukituki Minimum Flows                                                                                             265

Attachment 23:   Issue 15 Appendix 19 Barrie Riddler 31Mar17 Dry Land Farming Without Irrigation                                                                                        278

Attachment 24:   Issue 16 Appendix 20 Richard Measures NIWA 11Apr17 Flushing Flows Analysis                                                                                         334

Attachment 25:   Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 21 Shane Lambert HBRC Legal advice PC6 DIN levels & farmer obligations  1May2017                                        348

Attachment 26:   Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 22 Malcolm Miller April 2017 RWSS Resource Consents                                                                                       359

Attachment 27:   Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 23 Malcolm Miller table appended       361

Attachment 28:   Appendix 23A Summary of RWSS Resource Consents              367

Attachment 29:   Issue 19 Appendix 24 Dam to avoid DOC land 5Apr17               370

Attachment 30:   Issue 20 Appendix 25 Graeme Hansen Alternative Dam Sites Apr2017                                                                                                      375

Attachment 31:   Issue 20 Appendix 26 Additional Engineering info for Dan Elderkamp Apr17                                                                                             383

Attachment 32:   Issue 22 Appendix 27 Gravel seismic decommissioning Graeme Hansen 28Apr17                                                                                         388

Attachment 33:   Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow                                                              401

Attachment 34:   Issue 24 Appendix 29 Rob Waldron April 2017 Additional Info for Colin Riden                                                                                             428

Attachment 35:   Issue 24 Appendix 30 Kathleen Kozyniak 6Apr17 Annual Rainfall Data                                                                                                      434

   


Ruataniwha Water Storage Scheme Review Report

Attachment 4

 




 



















































































Issue 1 Appendix 1 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 29Nov16 Cover Letter

Attachment 5

 


Issue 1 Appendix 2 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 29Nov16 Land Swap Appeal Opinion

Attachment 6

 








Issue 2 Appendix 3 Sainsbury Logan and Williams 27Mar17 RWSS Withdrawal Process

Attachment 7

 








Issue 2 Appendix 4 Lara Bloomfield SLW PC6 without RWSS Liability Opinion 27Mar17

Attachment 8

 


Issue 2 Appendix 5 HBRC Public Notice PC6 4May13

Attachment 9

 


Issue 3 Appendix 6 Blair O'Keeffe Bell Gully 7Apr17 Memorandum RWSS shelving costs and liabilities

Attachment 10

 



Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review

Attachment 11

 






































Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review

Attachment 11

 


Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review

Attachment 11

 





Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review

Attachment 11

 


Issues 4 & 5 appendix 7 John Palairet Revenue & Expenditure & Impacts Review

Attachment 11

 





Issues 6 & 8 Appendix 8 Chris Morrison Lewis Tucker April 2017 Commercial Review Report

Attachment 12

 
















Issue 7 Appendix 9 Advice on barriers to faster uptake Blair O'Keeffe 17Mar17

Attachment 13

 



Issue 9 Appendix 10 Grant Pechey HBRC Butcher Report Summary 040517

Attachment 14

 

















Issue 9 Appendix 10 Grant Pechey HBRC Butcher Report Summary 040517

Attachment 14

 


Issue 10 Appendix 11 Tom Skerman 10Apr17 Downstream Production Demand

Attachment 15

 








Issue 12 Appendix 12 Ned Norton 7Apr17 Nutrient Leaching

Attachment 16

 

















Issue 12 Appendix 13 Memo Lachie Grant &  Ian Millner On-farm management practices

Attachment 17

 



















Issue 12 Appendix 13 Memo Lachie Grant &  Ian Millner On-farm management practices

Attachment 17

 


Issue 12 Appendix 13 Memo Lachie Grant &  Ian Millner On-farm management practices

Attachment 17

 


Issue 12 Appendix 14 WQE Memo from Andy Hicks to Ned Norton 13Apr17

Attachment 18

 









Issue 12 Appendix 15 Dougall Gordon 21Feb17 Groundwater Nitrate State and Trends Assessment

Attachment 19

 











Issue 12 Appendix 15 Dougall Gordon 21Feb17 Groundwater Nitrate State and Trends Assessment

Attachment 19

 


Issue 13 Appendix 16 Nathan Heath 6Apr17 PC6 without RWSS

Attachment 20

 









Issue 13 Appendix 17 Nathan Heath HBRC Appendices  6Apr17

Attachment 21

 



Issue 13 Appendix 17 Nathan Heath HBRC Appendices  6Apr17

Attachment 21

 




Issue 13 Appendix 17 Nathan Heath HBRC Appendices  6Apr17

Attachment 21

 



Issue 14 Appendix 18 John Bright Aqualinc 7Apr17 Tukituki Minimum Flows

Attachment 22

 






Issue 14 Appendix 18 John Bright Aqualinc 7Apr17 Tukituki Minimum Flows

Attachment 22

 





Issue 14 Appendix 18 John Bright Aqualinc 7Apr17 Tukituki Minimum Flows

Attachment 22

 





Issue 15 Appendix 19 Barrie Riddler 31Mar17 Dry Land Farming Without Irrigation

Attachment 23

 

























































Issue 16 Appendix 20 Richard Measures NIWA 11Apr17 Flushing Flows Analysis

Attachment 24

 















Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 21 Shane Lambert HBRC Legal advice PC6 DIN levels & farmer obligations  1May2017

Attachment 25

 







 






Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 22 Malcolm Miller April 2017 RWSS Resource Consents

Attachment 26

 



Issues 17 & 18 Appendix 23 Malcolm Miller table appended

Attachment 27

 







Appendix 23A Summary of RWSS Resource Consents

Attachment 28

 




Issue 19 Appendix 24 Dam to avoid DOC land 5Apr17

Attachment 29

 






Issue 20 Appendix 25 Graeme Hansen Alternative Dam Sites Apr2017

Attachment 30

 









Issue 20 Appendix 26 Additional Engineering info for Dan Elderkamp Apr17

Attachment 31

 






Issue 22 Appendix 27 Gravel seismic decommissioning Graeme Hansen 28Apr17

Attachment 32

 














Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow

Attachment 33

 











Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow

Attachment 33

 








Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow

Attachment 33

 


Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow

Attachment 33

 





Issue 24 Appendix 28 David Leong Tonkin Taylor 17Mar17 Makaroro Water Balance and Flow

Attachment 33

 






Issue 24 Appendix 29 Rob Waldron April 2017 Additional Info for Colin Riden

Attachment 34

 







Issue 24 Appendix 30 Kathleen Kozyniak 6Apr17 Annual Rainfall Data

Attachment 35